Idea of Pure Critique (Transversals: New Directions in by Iain MacKenzie

By Iain MacKenzie

The assumption of natural Critique should be valuable to scholars of Kant in addition to these drawn to Deleuze and Guattari's contribution to philosophies of distinction. extra essentially, the ebook provides a chain of stimulating political and philosophical demanding situations to the apathy and indifference that pervade glossy existence. what's required of critique whether it is to beat indifference? this question addresses middle subject matters in sleek, post-Kantian and ecu philosophy, hard theory's resignation within the face of latest political and monetary formations. during this publication, Iain Mackenzie argues eloquently that if such indifference is to be triumph over, critique needs to first be demarcated in its purity, as an concept of critique in and of itself. in addition, for the assumption of critique to develop into natural we needs to view it as being primarily the development of distinction. in simple terms during this natural shape, understood because the building of distinction, can critique wish to beat the crushing indifference of our present age.

Show description

Read Online or Download Idea of Pure Critique (Transversals: New Directions in Philosophy Series) PDF

Similar other social sciences books

Place, Commonality and Judgment: Continental Philosophy and the Ancient Greeks

During this very important and hugely unique booklet, position, commonality and judgment give you the framework during which works significant to the Greek philosophical and literary culture are usefully positioned and reinterpreted. Greek existence, it may be argued, used to be outlined by means of the interconnection of position, commonality and judgment.

Lebenswelt oder Natur. Schwacher Naturalismus und Naturbegriff bei Jürgen Habermas

In seinen neueren Veröffentlichungen tritt Jürgen Habermas immer wieder als prominenter Kritiker von Naturalismus und Szientismus auf. Er will die kommunikative Vernunft vor ihrer Reduktion auf die instrumentelle bewahren, ohne dabei hinter die Voraussetzungen dessen zurückzufallen, used to be er nachmetaphysisches Denken nennt.

Extra resources for Idea of Pure Critique (Transversals: New Directions in Philosophy Series)

Example text

In general terms, Deleuze and Guattari have diagnosed this problem as follows: 'whenever immanence is interpreted as immanent "to" something a confusion of plane and concept results, so that the concept becomes a transcendent universal and the plane becomes an attribute in the concept. ' While the terminology of plane and concept will be explored in the next chapter, the principal idea is that immanence can only avoid becoming transcendent if it remains wholly immanent to itself. By making the immanence of critique immanent to the auto-critique of reason (itself constrained by the sphere of experience), the possibility of a wholly immanent idea of critique is curtailed.

Admittedly, the idea that criticism is not circumscribed by justification is counter-intuitive but what we often take to be criticisms - the loud opinions of other citizens, the studied moralizing of philosophers - are not, when properly understood, criticisms at all. Although the phrase 'unjustified criticism' is a common part of our vocabulary, what is usually meant by this expression is the idea that someone is just giving us his or her own opinion of events. In this sense, 'unjustified criticism' might be better described as 'unwanted opinion'.

The idea of pure critique, therefore, is that which problematizes even the idea of critique itself. This may appear to push the idea of pure critique to the limits of comprehensibility, but before the construction of comprehension from out of these ashes of analysis can begin in earnest, we must push credulity even further. There is still a sense in which pure critique may be said to share a common 26 PHILOSOPHY AS PURE CRITIQUE ground with that which is under critical scrutiny, namely as regards the idea of the critic that carries out critical activity.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.60 of 5 – based on 47 votes